5 times two years ago. Alchemy Capital Management Deputy CIO Alok Agarwal says the index is now close to its cheapest level since the Covid pandemic, despite delivering no returns over the period.

Agarwal expects the next phase of gains to come from beyond large caps, with earnings growth emerging in mid and small-cap stocks and investment opportunities expanding across AI infrastructure, healthcare, manufacturing and selected defence companies. Edited excerpts from a chat: Why hasn't the Nifty really become cheap despite giving no returns in the last two years?

Were we that overvalued in September 2024? It has become relatively cheaper, in our view.

It may not feel cheap primarily due to no returns and slow earnings growth. 4x now in September 2026.

During this period, the Nifty50 has corrected by 11% while earnings kept growing (albeit at a subdued pace). So the multiple did the falling.

Current valuations are close to the lowest levels we have seen in the post-Covid era. Were we overvalued in 2024?

Stretched, yes. The one-year forward P/E was barely 8% below its all-time highs and well above historical averages.

All this happened while earnings growth slowed for nine straight quarters and remained in single digits. Prices have run ahead of profits, and the last two years have been a period of corrections.

Here's the thing. 5x (one-year forward P/E).

In our view, that's a panic price, not a fair value. What we have now is a reasonable one, which is where long-term returns usually start.

The Nifty has underperformed several pockets of the broader market this year, while many mid and small-cap companies have continued to deliver earnings growth. Is this structural broadening or a late-cycle rotation?

It appears to be structurally broadening, in our view, and earnings trends support this. A late-cycle rotation is often money chasing stories because the leaders are tired.

This time, the numbers are doing the work. So far in 2026, the Nifty50 is down about 10%, while the Nifty Midcap 150 Index is up 3%, the Nifty Smallcap 250 Index is up 10%, and the Nifty Microcap 250 Index is up 19%.

Behind that, Q1FY27 profits grew 23% for the Nifty Midcap 150 Index, and 31% for the Nifty Smallcap 250 Index, against 21% for the Nifty50. There's a quieter reason too.